v0670-635

IN THE

UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT

OF APPEALS

FOR THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT

WILLIAM C. OSBORNE, ELIZA A. ELZA. LOUIS D.

OSBORNE, LOUIS B. OSBORNE, CHARLES E.

OSBORNE, CLARENCE OSBORNE, HESTER E.

HOAG, MARY E. DAVENPORT, ALFRED W.

DOTY, HORACE O. DOTY, SUSIE OSBORNE,

MRS. HENRY BURTIS, MRS. JAMES WEBB,

RUFUS E. OSBORNE, S. WALLACE OSBORNE,

WILLIAM E. OSBORNE, ELIDA B. RUNDLE,

THEODORE S. OSBORNE, by his Conservator, S.

WALLACE OSBORNE. EDITH BAILEY, ELLA A. 1 ..fi Q

HANFORD, EMMA C. OSBORNE, MAGGIE I. K^^ J''''

SPARKS, ROBERT E. OSBORNE, MINNIE E.

HEGGEMAN, GEORGE I. OSBORNE, MRS. LOUIS

1. KING, ANNA E. DOTY. LAURA A. DOTY,

FRANK L. DOTY and HOWARD W. DOTY,

Appellants ,

vs.

CLAUDE C. RAMSAY, EBEN S. OSBORNE and

CHARLES F. MUNDAY. as Executors and Trust ees

of the Estate of James Osborne, deceased, and the

CITY OF SEATTLE, a Municipal Corporation.

Appellees.

Appeal from the United States Circuit Court for the

Western District of Washington, Northern

Division.

SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF OF APPELLEES.

CHAS. F. MUNDAY,

. Solicitor for Trustees, Appellees.

SCOTT CALHOUN,

Solicitor for City of Seattle, Appellee.

^- 1-

^ysfJf

---

archive.org Volume Name: govuscourtsca9briefs0670

Volume: http://archive.org/stream/govuscourtsca9briefs0670

Document Link: http://archive.org/stream/govuscourtsca9briefs0670#page/n634/mode/1up

Top Keywords (auto-generated):

osborne, doty, louis, james, proven, charles, seattle, city, william, wallace, trustees, solicitor, munday, identity, witnesses

Top Key Phrases (auto-generated):

james osborne, wallace osborne, evi dence, western district, webb rufus, susie osborne, sup posed, sparks robert, scott calhoun, rundle theodore, ramsay eben, proven cohabitation, personal interest, osborne william, osborne minnie

Document Status: UGLY